Location: Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Attendees:
- Karen Oportus INREV
- Elise van herwaarden, Researcher
- Jiri Brakenhoff, Researcher
Background
Karen Oportus works in the housing and real estate sector at INREV in Amsterdam. Although she is currently based in the Netherlands and professionally embedded in a European real estate context, her reflections in this interview are grounded in her personal, cultural, and lived experience of Chile.
Q: How have recent heat waves affected life in Santiago, in your experience (or in other Chilean cities)?
A: From what I understand, Chile has been experiencing drought for the last few years, obviously impacting agriculture and livestock. Beyond the climatic impact, water privatisation definitely worsens the national situation.
Q: What cultural habits in Santiago or other Chilean cities have historically helped people cope with heat?
A: As a Viñamarina, the heat has never really been a problem, the proximity to the ocean makes the climate cool and quite nice. However, I remember friends from Santiago telling me that their routines were affected by the heat, that they basically avoided going out until the evening because only then was it bearable. Also, every time I go to the capital it is law to carry a bottle of cold water with you and you constantly look for indoor spaces with air conditioning, otherwise you start to feel physical discomfort. You may even notice that street vendors come into the metro to sell ice water and people buy it in desperation. However, I can also notice that in comparison to me, coming from outside the capital, they are much more adapted to the climate than I am.
Q: Are these habits different across socio-economic backgrounds?
A: There are some general habits, but there is a contrast when it comes to people who have to work outdoors and can't do anything else but endure the heat. In that sense it is not the difference in habits but in the conditions they have to endure. Someone from a privileged background may well be in an air-conditioned home/office, much more comfortable than those who have to be outside to make ends meet, the latter just get creative and find ways to make it bearable.
Q: How do cultural habits intersect with spatial strategies for coping with heat?
A: I don't have a lot of knowledge in this regard but Santiago has a lot of parks and I get the impression that there has been some emphasis on maintaining them as they have become a regular social space. It is even possible to see the growth of shops, bars and restaurants within them. Certain malls also have outdoor spaces that follow the same concept, which was quite curious/novel to me being from another region. If I think about it in depth, I don't know if I've seen this so much in other countries.
However, this applies to a greater extent in the more privileged areas of Santiago in even Chile. Generally there is not much attention to the more vulnerable areas.
Q: If so, how does the municipality work with local communities to implement or co-create climate adaptation strategies?
A: I don't know about current measures but I can say that it depends very much on the government in power. In general left-wing politicians, mainly governors or mayors, have the intention to work with communities, but I have not heard of any measures regarding this issue specifically. Again, it may be because I am not from the capital.
We are still a country that is very much driven by populist discourse and in that sense, it is all about security, crime and immigration. A direct cause of ignorance and lack of transparency on the part of politicians and the media, especially TV channels.
However, I tend to hear a lot more strategies from communities, organisations and universities. This is something I really appreciate about Chile, traditional universities usually make you work with communities and can play an important social role, something I have not seen much abroad. Also, I think that the lack of governmental measures has given way to the development of independent organisations or start ups, it is crazy to see the huge amount of incredibly creative projects that arise and common to hear how many brains we are wasting by not investing in these types of projects and their development that end up going abroad.
Q: Are there traditional or vernacular architectural and urban design strategies that have historically been used to reduce heat?
A: It is not my field of expertise but I do remember a Chilean architect talking about this and its impact on heat regulation. Especially because the typical glass design has become incredibly popular in cities yet it is terrible when it comes to sustainability.
Q: What role do public buildings (e.g., libraries, cultural centres, museums, indoor markets) play in offering relief from heat?
A: I talked about this in my previous answers but indeed, I can say that personally I would always go to cafés, however the average Chilean can't afford to do that all the time. Cultural centres have become very trendy in the last few years, but I would dare say that they are still more oriented to the privileged sectors, that's why I think that parks become the common and popular social environment.
Q: Are there local design principles or philosophies that could be applied internationally?
A: I don't know if I have a slightly controversial opinion but the truth is that sometimes I find it a bit shocking that in Europe you always have to do something about it, that you look for an air purifier, a humidifier, that there has to be central heating etc etc. And the truth is I just find it spoiled behaviour. Of course people should work in optimal conditions but to what extent do we create needs? personally I have never heard of such things in Chile. People buy a fan or an electric heater and that's it. Central heating is the only one that makes sense to me and it has only been included in newer buildings in the last decade. Mine doesn't have it and to this day we turn on the electric heater for a while (nowadays you find more and more sustainable options) or we go to bed with a heating blanket or a hot water bottle.
Perhaps because we are a highly seismic country, we have always put emphasis on having good buildings, beyond aesthetics, they are quite strong and well insulated (in the latter, at least the newer ones). I appreciate Europe's passion for taking care of buildings and its historical heritage but, again, to what extent do we emphasise that rather than optimal constructions? obviously destroying and building something has a major climatic impact but retrofitting is not always worth it. I am not an expert on the subject, I just think that certain things have to be put in the balance with a more critical and social eye.
Finally, I really appreciate the social role of universities, in psychology I had to work weekly with communities, companies, schools and patients for years and I know that in other professions a similar dynamic is followed. It is about putting theory into practice with a critical and social outlook, real knowledge is in the communities. Classrooms give you the basics but a cultural and social perspective is always required as research tends to biased.
Q: How do you perceive the role of behavioral change versus technical intervention in effective adaptation?
A: In the Chilean case, the role of behavioural change versus technical intervention cannot be assessed in isolation. Both elements are necessary, but they must be deeply anchored in the cultural and social context for adaptation to be truly effective.
Chile is a country with great climatic, social and economic diversity, so any adaptation strategy - be it technical or behavioural - must consider local particularities. It is not enough to import technical solutions if the habits, beliefs and cultural barriers of the population are not understood.
For example, in many homes in central and southern Chile, inefficient ventilation and the use of wood-burning stoves are still common. Although cleaner technologies exist, if people do not perceive direct benefits, accessibility or consistency with their daily practices, real change does not occur.
In addition, there is also a significant distrust of institutions and interventions that are perceived as imposed ‘from above’. Therefore, effective adaptation requires participatory processes that integrate local knowledge, customs and ways of inhabiting the territory.
Behavioural change not only complements the technical intervention, but is the bridge that allows for its acceptance and sustainability over time. Solutions must be culturally meaningful, not only technically efficient.